web analytics

Menu

Skip to content
Shades of Knife
  • Home
  • True Colors of a Vile Wife
  • Need Inspiration?
  • Blog Updates
  • SOK Gallery
  • Vile News Reporter
  • About Me
  • Contact Me

Shades of Knife

True Colors of a Vile Wife

Tag: 2-Judge (Division) Bench Decision

Sonal Talpada Vs Veerbhan Singh on 2 Jun 2026

Posted on November 16 by ShadesOfKnife

A two-Judge bench of the Supreme Court held as follows,

From Para 19,

19. As held in the case of Samar Ghosh (supra) and other catena of judgments by this Court, denial of conjugal rights including persistent refusal of sexual intercourse without a reasonable cause constitutes mental cruelty and is a valid ground for divorce under Section 13(1)(ia) of the HMA. The courts in India have repeatedly established that withholding sexual intimacy inflicts severe emotional distress and undermines the bedrock of marriage. Therefore, the conclusion of the High Court is sustained. The decree of divorce as granted by allowing the appeal of the Respondent-husband is upheld.

From Paras 25 and 26,

25. In the light of the above, it can be said that the High Court has rightly assessed that where parties have been living separately for several years and at this stage asking them to live together after a prolonged duration would amount to cruelty to both the parties and divorce can be granted on this ground as provided under section 13 (1)(ia) of HMA. It may be added here that desertion as a ground requires an initial period as mentioned under the statute but if such desertion continues for a long period of time without any effort on the part of the parties to restore cohabitation would itself be a ground to be considered by the Appellate Court. This we say in the light of the fact that human relations are dynamic and once the initial mandate under the statute stands satisfied, continuation thereof during the litigation would aggravate the said agony which could be confirmational in substantiating the basis and pleaded ground for divorce. The same can be taken into consideration for formation of an opinion to accept the prayer by the Appellate Court. Appeal is the continuation of a suit and therefore, the Appellate Court would be entitled and justified to consider the conduct of the parties during the pendency of litigation. The same can also be looked into to support or reject an opinion on the ground in question.

26. An Appellate Court, while carefully ensuring that a party does not profit from their own manifest wrong or unilateral desertion, may legitimately treat a prolonged period of separation as an indicator of mental cruelty within the meaning of Section 13(1)(ia) of the HMA. The Appellate Court is not precluded from examining whether continuous separation over a substantial period, coupled with absence of any genuine effort at reconciliation, complete cessation of cohabitation and emotional alienation has resulted in mental cruelty. Subsequent events occurring during pendency of proceedings may legitimately be taken into consideration while undertaking such assessment. In such circumstances, the confirmation of a decree of divorce by an Appellate Court is not an invocation of extraordinary constitutional jurisdiction under Article 142 of the Constitution of India, but a lawful and realistic application of the statutory ground of cruelty to the facts of the case.

From Paras 29 and 37,

29. In any event, this Court in exercise of power to do “complete justice” under Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India has the discretion to dissolve the marriage on the ground of irretrievable breakdown.

37. In the light of what has been stated above, in our considered view, this would be a fit case where the relationship of marriage should come to an end for which exercise of powers under Article 142 of the Constitution of India would be essential to do complete justice. Accordingly, the marriage between the Appellant-wife and the Respondent-husband deserves to be dissolved in exercise of powers under Article 142 of the Constitution of India.

The wife’s appeal was dismissed and the High Court’s decree of divorce was upheld on the ground of cruelty; the Court also dissolved the marriage in exercise of Article 142 (Paras 19, 37 and 38).

1-Sonal-Talpada-Vs-Veerbhan-Singh-on-02-Jun-2026

Citations: 2026 INSC 620; Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 10422 of 2025.

Other Sources:

https://www.livelaw.in/sc-judgments/2026-livelaw-sc-594-sonal-talpada-v-veerbhan-singh-536743


Index of Divorce Cases here.

Posted in Supreme Court of India Judgment or Order or Notification | Tagged 2-Judge (Division) Bench Decision Article 142 - Enforcement of decrees and orders of Supreme Court and orders as to discovery etc Divorce Granted on Cruelty ground Irretrievable Breakdown of Marriage Reportable Judgement or Order Sonal Talpada Vs Veerbhan Singh | Leave a comment

Dhananjay Rathi Vs Ruchika Rathi on 13 Apr 2026

Posted on November 16 by ShadesOfKnife

A two-Judge bench of the Supreme Court held as follows,

From Paras 29 to 31,

29. However, the Respondent-Wife refused to honour the terms of the Settlement Agreement and refused to sign the Second Motion Petition stating that she had withdrawn her consent from the divorce. Though it is well within the law, for any party, to withdraw consent at any stage before grant of divorce by mutual agreement, however, in case a compromise deed or a settlement agreement has been entered in between the parties regarding the full and final settlement of their disputes, then in that case it is not open for the party to step back from the terms and conditions so arrived between them.

30. It is trite law that once the parties have entered into a settlement agreement which was duly authenticated by the mediator, in case of any resilement from such terms as agreed upon in the settlement, the resiling party must be encumbered with heavy costs. Any deviation from the terms of the settlement arrived in mediation and later confirmed by the Court should be dealt with strictly as such deviation harbors an attack to the foundational basis of the entire process of mediation.

31. The exception to the above rule is that a party can resile from the Settlement Agreement arrived in the mediation proceedings is, if it successfully demonstrates that the said Settlement Agreement was procured by force, fraud or undue influence. The party can also resile from the Settlement Agreement on account of non-fulfillment of any of the conditions by the opposite party as set out in the Settlement Agreement.

From Paras 37 and 41 (DV Act proceedings),

37. A careful perusal of the complaint filed by the Respondent-Wife under the DV Act depicts that there are no specific allegations regarding any sort of domestic violence that could emanate from the pleadings. The Respondent-Wife has failed to mention any event describing any sort of violence carried out either by the Appellant-Husband or his mother. A criminal complaint regarding domestic violence, with mere reference to the names of the family members or the husband without any specific allegation that points towards their active involvement in commission of such an act of violence, shall be nipped in the bud.

41. Therefore, we are of the view that the proceedings under the DV Act as initiated by the Respondent-Wife are liable to be quashed, the continuance of which would be an abuse of the process of law.

From Para 53 (Article 142),

53. Thus, in the light of the abovestated facts, we conclude that the present is a fit case for exercise of powers under Article 142(1) to grant a divorce as there had been an irretrievable breakdown of the marriage. Prevailing Position of the Settlement between the Parties

Conclusion: The criminal appeal was allowed, DV Complaint No. 3186/2025 was quashed and the marriage was dissolved under Article 142(1) on the terms of the mediated Settlement Agreement, with all other proceedings between the parties closed (Para 55).

2-Dhananjay-Rathi-Vs-Ruchika-Rathi-on-13-Apr-2026

Citations: 2026 INSC 360; Criminal Appeal No. 1924 of 2026 (arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 1878 of 2026).

Other Sources:

https://www.livelaw.in/sc-judgments/2026-livelaw-sc-366-dhananjay-rathi-versus-ruchika-rathi-530195

 


Index of Divorce Cases here.

Index of Domestic Violence Cases here.

Posted in Supreme Court of India Judgment or Order or Notification | Tagged 2-Judge (Division) Bench Decision Article 142 - Enforcement of decrees and orders of Supreme Court and orders as to discovery etc Dhananjay Rathi Vs Ruchika Rathi HM Act 13(B) - MCD Granted After Settlement Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act 2005 Reportable Judgement or Order | Leave a comment

Ritu Gupta Vs Anupam Bipul on 12 Mar 2026

Posted on November 16 by ShadesOfKnife

A Division Bench of Jharkhand High Court held as follows,

From Paras 70 and 72,

70. It is considered view of this Court that the allegation of impotency against the husband would necessarily affect the reputation of the husband and the complaining of incapacity of the husband to bear children, without any proof creates an intense mental agony and anguish of the husband and such conduct amounts to mental cruelty.

72. In the instant case wife (appellant herein) made serious allegation of impotency against her husband, which has not been corroborated from the medical opinion which has been placed before this Court in compliance of the order dated 05.12.2025. Moreover, launching criminal prosecution on false statement by either spouse, amounts to mental cruelty, therefore this Court is of the considered view that the learned Family Court has rightly derived his inferences that the conduct of defendant/appellant amount to cruelty against her respondent husband as she brought criminal prosecution against him on basis of loose statement.

Conclusion: The wife’s appeal against the Family Court’s decree of divorce under Section 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act was dismissed (Paras 74 and 75).

1-3-Ritu-Gupta-Vs-Anupam-Bipul-on-12-Mar-2026

Citations: 2026:JHHC:6760-DB; F.A. No. 63 of 2025.

Other Sources:

https://indiankanoon.org/doc/131505390/

 


Index of Divorce Cases here.

Posted in High Court of Jharkhand Judgment or Order or Notification | Tagged 2-Judge (Division) Bench Decision Divorce Granted on Cruelty ground HM Act - Alleging Importency Falsely Causes Mental Cruelty Ritu Gupta Vs Anupam Bipul | Leave a comment

Sushila Vs Joginder on 13 Sep 2023

Posted on November 6 by ShadesOfKnife

A division bench of Delhi High Court held as follows,

From Para 11,

11. The Divorce Petition was filed in the year 2007. After the Divorce Petition was filed, the appellant-wife got registered an FIR bearing No. 106/2008 under Sections 498A/406/34 I.P.C. at P.S.Nangloi against the respondent-husband and his family members though they have been acquitted vide the judgment dated 16.03.2023. The appellant-wife had also filed a complaint under Section 12 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (hereinafter referred to as ‘D.V. Act’) against the respondent-husband but the same was also disposed of on 30.09.2022. A complaint case under Section 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Cr.P.C’) titled Sushila Vs. Joginder was filed which is pending adjudication before the Malhila Court, Rohini. Further, a complaint case titled Sushila Devi Vs. Sehnoor Khan & Ors. was also filed which is pending trial before the learned M.M., Tis Hazari Courts.

From Para 23,

23. Significantly, according to the respondent-husband, though the parties started residing in the same house but they were living as strangers. The appellant-wife denied him conjugal relationship and whenever he approached her, she threatened him to commit suicide. Again, there is no serious rebuttal of this testimony of the respondent-husband which again reflects that there was breakdown of conjugal relationship which is the bedrock of any matrimonial relationship.

From Para 34,

34. Be that as it may, the allegations of appellant-wife are that the respondent-husband had got married. However, neither any specific details nor any proof whatsoever of the alleged second marriage has been tendered on record or given in the complaints mentioned above. Even if it is accepted that the respondent-husband has started living with another woman and has two sons during the pendency of Divorce Petition, that in itself, cannot be termed as cruelty in the peculiar circumstances of this case when the parties have not been co-habiting since 2005. After such long years of separation with no possibility of re-union, the respondent-husband may have found his peace and comfort by living with another woman, but, that is a subsequent event during the pendency of the Divorce Petition and cannot disentitle the husband from divorce from the wife on the proven grounds of cruelty. Moreover, the consequence of such liaison shall be borne by the respondent-husband, the woman and the children. The appellant-wife has not been able to prove any other act of cruelty by the respondent-husband disentitling the respondent-husband from taking divorce.

Sushila Vs Joginder on 13 Sep 2023

Citations:

Other Sources:

https://indiankanoon.org/doc/114898556/

https://www.barandbench.com/news/husband-cohabiting-another-woman-long-separation-wifenotcruelty-delhi-high-court

https://www.verdictum.in/court-updates/high-courts/husband-living-with-another-woman-couple-not-in-cohabitation-for-long-time-not-cruelty-delhi-hc-1494973

https://www.legitquest.com/case/sushila-v-joginder/788926


Index of Divorce Judgments is here.

Posted in High Court of Delhi Judgment or Order or Notification | Tagged 2-Judge (Division) Bench Decision Divorce Granted on Cruelty ground Divorce Granted to Husband HM Act Sec 13 - Divorce Granted to Husband HM Act Sec 13 - Divorce Granted to Husband on Acquittal from IPC 498A case Sushila Vs Joginder | Leave a comment

Thangam Venkatesh Vs State of Tamil Nadu and Ors on 23 Oct 2026

Posted on October 29 by ShadesOfKnife

A division bench at Madurai of Madras High Court held as follows,

From Para 6, (Slipper shot #1)

6. Even though the law has thus been declared in categorical terms, we notice in recent times that there are egregious breaches. Mr.Badrudeen Mustafa, an MLA representing the Madurai Central Constituency where the famed Meenakshi temple is located, went inside the temple premises soon after his election. He claimed that he had a right to inspect if proper amenities are being provided. He also went up the temple towers on the occasion of Kumbabishekam. It is ironical that the said MLA proclaimed that Sanatana Dharma ought to eradicated.

From Para 7, (Slipper shot #2)

7. We take judicial notice of the fact that a Hon’ble Minister who is a Christian by faith, entered Thiruchendur temple without giving the undertaking required from Non-Hindus. We have the illustrious instance of the Hon’ble Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu Shri Joseph Vijay who worshipped Goddess Meenakshi after signing the undertaking. The Hon’ble Chief Minister who is a Christian by faith was not asked to convert to Hinduism. He was only requested to affirm his reverence for the deity. This is what we call as an inclusive approach. We recall instances from the holy life of Kanchi Maha Periyava. When some foreigners and persons belonging to other faiths would express their desire to embrace Hinduism, he not only discouraged them but called upon them to show greater fidelity to their faith. When Justice Ismail of the Madras High Court used to visit him, Periyava respected the great judge’s sentiments by giving him sandal wood paste instead of ‘Viboothi’.

From Para 8, (Slipper shot #3)

8. … We take judicial notice of a video doing rounds in the social media of persons wearing skull caps, pushing their way through in Thiruvannamali Arunachaleswarar temple, notwithstanding the vigorous protests of the devotees. The HR&CE staff stood as mute spectators.

From Para 11, (Slipper shot #4)

11. That is why, we deem it necessary to render an authoritative pronouncement. We made it clear at the very outset that the scope of this judgment is confined to Agamic temples. Lord Ayyapa has devotees cutting across religions. Shirdi Sai Baba is also beyond religion. Both Hindus as well as Muslims claimed him as their own. Of course now, he is more a part of the Hindu pantheon.

From Paras 16 and 17,

16. We do not want to stop with citing precedents. The statutory provisions are equally clear. Section 10 of the HR&CE Act makes it clear that every person from the Commissioner to the last grade servant shall profess the Hindu religion. Section 24(3) of the HR&CE Act makes it clear that even the officers under the Act, shall have due regard to the religious practice or usage, while exercising the right of entry within the premises of the institution. Section 24(4) states that nothing in Section 24 of the Act shall be deemed to authorise any person who is not a Hindu to enter the premises or place referred to in the provision.
17. The petitioner herein is a Hindu. He is entitled to insist that the trustees of the various Agamic temples in Tamil Nadu uphold the Agamic
injunctions by not permitting non-Hindus who do not sign the undertaking from crossing the flag-pole. If such entry is permitted, it would defile the sanctity of the temple. We intend to go a step further. Even entry into the temple premises, cannot be permitted for non-Hindus who sport their religious markers and who do not subscribe their reverence for the deity concerned. This subscription must be in the format prescribed by the institution concerned. We say so by deriving inspiration from Kalyan Dass wherein it was observed that the entire temple precincts has to be held sacrosanct and also the statutory definition found in the 1947 Act. This writ petition is allowed on these terms. No costs.


Citations:

Other Sources:

 

 

Posted in High Court of Madras Judgment or Order or Notification | Tagged 2-Judge (Division) Bench Decision Catena of Landmark Judgments Referred/Cited to Landmark Case Reportable Judgement or Order Thangam Venkatesh Vs State of Tamil Nadu and Ors | Leave a comment

Mahesh Kumar Agarwal Vs Union of India and Anr on 19 Dec 2025

Posted on October 27 by ShadesOfKnife

A division bench of Supreme Court of India held as follows,

From Para 14,

14. We are also unable to agree with the view that the appellant could not fall within GSR 570(E) because the NIA Court did not itself mention “ten years” in its order. The appellant’s application before that court specifically sought renewal for ten years. The NIA Court granted no objection for renewal, released the passport for that limited purpose, directed redeposit after renewal and prohibited the appellant from obtaining any visa or travelling abroad without its permission. The Delhi High Court, dealing with the conviction in the CBI case, then expressly held that there was no basis to deny renewal “for a regular period of ten years” and granted permission accordingly, while continuing the condition that the appellant shall not leave the country without its permission.Read together, in the manner envisaged by the OM dated 10.10.2019, these orders supply both the requisite judicial permission and a clear indication of the period of validity. In such circumstances, the Passport Authority and the Calcutta High Court were not justified in treating Section 6(2)(f) as continuing to operate in full force so as to deny renewal altogether.

From Para 16,

16. The respondents and the Calcutta High Court have also treated the expression “permission to depart from India” in GSR 570(E) as if it necessarily refers only to a concrete permission for an immediately proposed journey. We do not read the notification in so narrow a manner. Where, as here, the conditions of bail already stipulate that the appellant shall not leave the country without prior permission of the court concerned, and the same court
then grants no objection to renewal of the passport without relaxing that condition, the requirement that departure from India shall be subject to judicial permission is built into the very terms of the exemption. The passport authority is not required, at the renewal stage, to demand a schedule of future journeys or visas which may not yet exist. Its task is to see whether, despite pending proceedings, the criminal courts have chosen to keep the possibility of travel open under their supervision. Once that position is clear, GSR 570(E) applies and the bar under Section 6(2)(f) cannot be invoked to refuse renewal altogether.

From Para 24,

24. Finally, even on the respondents’ own reading of GSR 570(E), the consequence of an order which does not specify a longer period of validity is that the passport should be issued for a shorter duration, usually one year, and not that renewal must be refused altogether. The learned Single Judge and the Division Bench did not examine this aspect, because they proceeded on the premise that the appellant stood outside the exemption altogether. Once it is recognised that the appellant is within the exempted class, the correct question for the passport authority is the appropriate period of validity in the facts of the case, not whether any renewal is permissible at all. In the present matter, given that the Delhi High Court has expressly authorised renewal for ten years and the NIA Court has imposed stringent conditions including redeposit and prior permission for travel, we see no justification to curtail the normal period of validity.

Mahesh Kumar Agarwal Vs Union of India and Anr on 19 Dec 2025

Citations:

Other Sources:

 


Index of Passport related Judgments is here.

Posted in Supreme Court of India Judgment or Order or Notification | Tagged 2-Judge (Division) Bench Decision Legal Procedure Explained - Interpretation of Statutes Mahesh Kumar Agarwal Vs Union of India and Anr No Court Permission required for Passport Renewal Passport Renewal for 10 Years Reportable Judgement or Order | Leave a comment

Rajkumar Madki Vs Dr. Shailendra Beldale on 16 Oct 2026

Posted on October 20 by ShadesOfKnife

A division bench of the Apex Court held that a private complaint is maintainable against a lying public servant in the nomination form contains false statements.

From Para 4,

4. A substantial question of law of general public importance, hitherto undecided by this Court, does arise for our consideration. It is:
Whether Section 125-A of the RoP Act should pass muster the rigours of Section 195(1) of the Cr. PC? In other words, whether any private person can file a complaint under Section 200 of the Cr. PC against a returned candidate for an offence punishable under Section 125-A of the RoP Act?

From Para 11,

11. It is significant to note that sub-clauses (i) to (iii) of clause (a) of sub-section (1) of Section 195(1) of the Cr. PC impose a statutory prohibition on a court in relation to taking cognisance of offences punishable under Sections 172 to 188, IPC or of abetment of/attempt to/criminal conspiracy to commit such offences, except on the complaint in writing of the public servant concerned or of some other public servant to whom he is administratively subordinate. It is plain that the text of clause (a) of sub-section (1) of Section 195 does not include Section 125-A of the RoP Act. Should we read into Section 195, Cr. PC a prohibition in respect of Section 125-A of the RoP Act also, apart from those expressly included? If indeed it were the intention of the legislature that cognizance of any offence relating to furnishing of false information by a candidate in an affidavit with intent of being elected in an election (referred to in Section 125-A of the RoP Act) could only be taken if the complainant were a public servant, the same could have been provided by an amendment of Section 195, Cr. PC since Section 125-A of the RoP Act is of fairly recent origin. Significantly, Section 125-A was inserted in the RoP Act with effect from 24th August, 2002, while it is noticed that Section 195, Cr. PC suffered an amendment thereafter in April, 2006. The legislature is presumed to be conscious of its insertion of Section 125-A in the RoP Act four years back. It stands to reason that omission of the legislature to include Section 125-A of the RoP Act in Section 195, Cr. PC is deliberate and no court, in terms of the latter provision, would be barred from taking cognizance of an alleged offence under Section 125-A of the RoP Act, even on the complaint lodged by a private person. This interpretation is also fortified by the absence of any provision in any enactment stipulating that a complaint in relation to an offence under Section 125-A of the RoP Act can only be lodged by a public servant as well as the ordainment in Section 125-A that the penalty it envisages is “notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force”. This means that the rigour of Section 195, Cr. PC would not be applicable insofar as a complaint lodged by a private person, alleging an offence under Section 125-A of the RoP Act, under Section 200, Cr. PC, is concerned, whereby the court is urged to penalise the offender for furnishing false information in an affidavit to get elected. The High Court was, therefore, clearly in error in returning the finding that it did.

From Para 13,

13. In conclusion, we hold that a private complaint alleging offence committed under Section 125-A, RoP Act need not pass muster of the rigours of Section 195, Cr. PC, as held by the High Court. If at all a complaint is lodged to harass an elected candidate or frivolous allegations are levelled therein, the laws of the country duly equip and empower the competent magistrates to pass such order(s) as they deem fit and proper commensurate with the facts and circumstances of each case.

Rajkumar Madki Vs Dr. Shailendra Beldale on 16 Oct 2026

Citations:

Other Sources:

 


 

Posted in Supreme Court of India Judgment or Order or Notification | Tagged 2-Judge (Division) Bench Decision CrPC 195 - Prosecution for contempt of lawful authority of public servants or for offences against public justice and for offences relating to documents given in evidence Election Matter Legal Procedure Explained - Interpretation of Statutes Rajkumar Madki Vs Dr. Shailendra Beldale Reportable Judgement or Order Representation of People Act 1951 Sec 125A - Penalty for filing false affidavit etc. | Leave a comment

Ram Singh Vs State of UP on 21 Feb 2024

Posted on October 19 by ShadesOfKnife

A division bench of Supreme Court granted benefit of doubt to petitioner since on same set of evidence co-accused was acquitted.

From Para 6.3,

6.3. He further submits that the trial court had committed a fundamental error in convicting the appellant on the one hand and acquitting the co-accused Lala Ram on the other hand. Evidence against both were the same. When on the same set of evidence the co-accused was acquitted, the trial court ought to have acquitted the appellant as well. This aspect was overlooked by the High Court. In support of his submission, learned counsel has placed reliance on a decision of this Court in Javed Shaukat Ali Qureshi Vs. State of Gujarat, (2023) 9 SCC 164.

From Para 33,

33. Thus, on a careful analysis of the evidence on record, we are of the view that the appellant should be given the benefit of doubt as according to us, the prosecution could not prove his guilt beyond all reasonable doubt. Any lingering doubt about the involvement of an accused in the crime he is accused of committing, must weigh on the mind of the court and in such a situation, the benefit of doubt must be given to the accused. This is more so when the co-accused is acquitted by the trial court on the same set of evidence.

Ram Singh Vs State of UP on 21 Feb 2024

Ram Singh Vs State of UP on 21 Feb 2024 (SCR)

Citations:

Other Sources:

 


Highlights:

FIR in 1982 and Conviction by Sessions Court in 1983.
Appeal in High Court filed in 1983 and Dismissed in 2018.
Criminal Appeal in Supreme Court filed in 2018 and Allowed in 2026.


Index of Quash Judgments is here.

Posted in Supreme Court of India Judgment or Order or Notification | Tagged 2-Judge (Division) Bench Decision Benefit of Doubt - Co-Accused acquitted on the same set of evidence Benefit of Doubt - View Favourable to Accused Ram Singh Vs State of UP Reportable Judgement or Order | Leave a comment

Secretary to Government Vs Sameer Ahamed N and Ors on 15 Oct 2026

Posted on October 15 by ShadesOfKnife

A two-Judge bench of the Supreme Court held as follows,

From Para 61(a), (c), (e) and (f),

a) A person who converts from a Hindu social order to a non-Hindu social order cannot claim affirmative action under Article 16(4) of the Constitution merely on the basis of the social backwardness associated with his pre-conversion status; the backwardness suffered in the antecedent social order cannot, by itself, be carried forward so as to confer upon him the status of a backward class in the religion to which he has converted.
c) Conversion to a non-Hindu social order does not, by itself, confer membership of any particular notified Backward Class community. A person’s pre-conversion caste or community status cannot, merely by reason of conversion, be transposed into membership of a distinct notified Backward Class community in the post-conversion social order. The social backwardness which formed the basis of the person’s pre-conversion status cannot, by itself, furnish the legal foundation for conferring upon him membership of a different notified Backward Class community after conversion.
e) No statutory benefit, protection, reservation or other entitlement under Article 16(4) of the Constitution, the enjoyment of which is predicated upon a particular Hindu social order, can be claimed or extended merely on the basis of such antecedent membership after the person has converted to Islam, Christianity or any other non-Hindu social order. Such conversion severs the legal foundation of an entitlement which is specifically conditioned upon membership of that Hindu social order.
f) A community certificate is declaratory of, and does not create or confer, the status which it purports to recognise. Neither the issuance of a community certificate nor an executive instruction can enlarge, modify or dispense with the substantive constitutional and statutory conditions governing membership of the class or entitlement to the benefits attached thereto.

From Para 54,

Reservation is attached to a constitutionally identified class and not to an individual as a transferable personal entitlement. The constitutional enquiry is directed to the class, its common characteristics and the disadvantage which binds its members together…

From Paras 62 and 63 (Conclusion),

62. We therefore affirm the central conclusion of the High Court, though our reasoning proceeds on the constitutional foundations set out above. A person who converts to Islam does not, by that act alone, become a member of any one of the seven notified Backward Class Muslim communities in the State. His former caste or community status cannot automatically be transposed into the Muslim Backward Class category, nor can a private religious body conclusively determine such statutory entitlement.
63. Tested on that standard, we are of the view that the impugned G.O. cannot be sustained and has rightly been quashed by the High Court. It creates an artificial route by which a person moves from a pre-conversion backward social order into a notified Muslim backward class without establishing the necessary social and legal link.

The Special Leave Petition against the Madras High Court’s quashing of G.O.(Ms) No. 31 dated 09.03.2024 was dismissed (Para 64).

Secretary to Government Vs Sameer Ahamed N and Ors on 15 Oct 2026

Citations: 2026 INSC 1129; SLP (C) No. 25507/2026 (Diary No. 39624/2026).

Other Sources:

 


The Judgment of Madras High Court bench at Madurai is here.

Sameer Ahamed Vs The District Collector and Ors on 25 Jun 2026

The GO issued that got struck down as unconstitutional in this context is here.

2024-03-09 Converts to Islam from BC

Posted in Supreme Court of India Judgment or Order or Notification | Tagged 2-Judge (Division) Bench Decision Conversion - No Automatic Backward Class Status Landmark Case Reportable Judgement or Order Secretary to Government Vs Sameer Ahamed N and Ors | Leave a comment

Janki Vashdeo Bhojwani and Anr Vs Indusind Bank Ltd and Ors on 6 Dec 2004

Posted on October 12 by ShadesOfKnife

A division bench of the Apex Court held as follows, with respect to what a GPA-holder can do and not.

Order III, Rules 1 and 2 CPC, empowers the holder of power of attorney to “act” on behalf of the principal. In our view the word “acts” employed in Order III, Rules 1 and 2 CPC, confines only in respect of “acts” done by the power of attorney holder in exercise of power granted by the instrument. The term “acts” would not include deposing in place and instead of the principal. In other words, if the power of attorney holder has rendered some “acts” in pursuance to power of attorney, he may depose for the principal in respect of such acts, but he cannot depose for the principal for the acts done by the principal and not by him. Similarly, he cannot depose for the principal in respect of the matter which only the principal can have a personal knowledge and in respect of which the principal is entitled to be cross-examined.

Janki Vashdeo Bhojwani and Anr Vs Indusind Bank Ltd and Ors on 6 Dec 2004

Citations: [2004 SUPP. 6 S.C.R. 681], [2004 INSC 695], [AIR 2005 SUPREME COURT 439], [2005 (2) SCC 217], [2004 AIR SCW 7064, (2007) 2 NIJ 395], [2005 (2) SRJ 281], [(2004) 10 JT 264 (SC)], [(2005) 3 CTC 128 (SC)], [(2005) 3 MAD LJ 109], [2004 (10) JT 264, (2005) 1 CLR 737 (SC)], [(2005) 3 JCR 175 (SC)], [2004 (10) SCALE 244, 2005 (2) ALL CJ 924], [2004 (7) SLT 441], [(2005) ILR (KANT) 729], [(2005) 1 ALL WC 138], [(2004) 63 CORLA 174], [(2005) 1 RECCIVR 240], [(2005) 3 MAD LW 403], [(2004) 10 SCALE 244], [(2005) 1 SCJ 520], [(2005) 2 CIVILCOURTC 324, (2005) 2 LANDLR 585], [(2005) 98 REVDEC 371], [(2005) 3 ANDHLD 43], [(2005) 3 SUPREME 275], [(2005) 1 WLC(SC)CVL 245], [(2005) 1 CAL HN 175], [(2005) 123 COMCAS 154], [(2005) 1 MAH LJ 1170, (2005) 1 MPLJ 421], [(2005) 2 PUN LR 1], [(2005) 1 KCCR 227], [(2005) 58 ALL LR 440], [(2005) 2 ANDH LT 57, (2005) 2 KER LT 265], [(2005) 58 ALL LR 610], [(2005) 1 ALL RENTCAS 409], [(2005) 3 CIVLJ 775], [(2005) 2 CURCC 61], [(2005) 1 ALL WC 831], [(2005) 1 BANKCLR 438], [(2005) 3 BOM CR 846]

Other Sources:

 


Index

Posted in Supreme Court of India Judgment or Order or Notification | Tagged 2-Judge (Division) Bench Decision Janki Vashdeo Bhojwani and Anr Vs Indusind Bank Ltd and Ors Landmark Case Power of Attorney Reportable Judgement or Order | Leave a comment

Post navigation

  • Older posts

Search within entire Content of “Shades of Knife”

My Legal X Timeline

Advocate Sandeep Pamarati 🇮🇳💪👨🏻‍🎓 Follow

AP High Court Advocate with M Tech (CS) || 12 years in 'Software Industry' as Solution Architect || Blogs at https://t.co/29CB9BzK4w || #TDPTwitter

SandeepPamarati
Retweet on Twitter Advocate Sandeep Pamarati 🇮🇳💪👨🏻‍🎓 Retweeted
exsecular

exsecular

Verified account @exsecular ·
8 Nov

Chor era ( don’t forget they hired 24 lawyers against Ram mandir ) to Modi Era 🚩🚩🔥🔥🚩🚩

Reply on Twitter 2119236931808862565 Retweet on Twitter 2119236931808862565 252 Like on Twitter 2119236931808862565 888 X 2119236931808862565
Retweet on Twitter Advocate Sandeep Pamarati 🇮🇳💪👨🏻‍🎓 Retweeted
bjp4india

BJP

Verified account @bjp4india ·
8 Nov

This never gets old... Happy Diwali to you-know-who! 😉🪔

Reply on Twitter 2119407089118302307 Retweet on Twitter 2119407089118302307 3289 Like on Twitter 2119407089118302307 23533 X 2119407089118302307
Retweet on Twitter Advocate Sandeep Pamarati 🇮🇳💪👨🏻‍🎓 Retweeted
ani

ANI

Verified account @ani ·
7 Nov

#WATCH | Ayodhya, Uttar Pradesh: At Ram ki Paidi, visitor Simona from Ukraine says, "... My sister invited me. I really like everything here. I am amazed by how beautiful everything looks..."

Reply on Twitter 2119119499194675541 Retweet on Twitter 2119119499194675541 899 Like on Twitter 2119119499194675541 7112 X 2119119499194675541
Retweet on Twitter Advocate Sandeep Pamarati 🇮🇳💪👨🏻‍🎓 Retweeted
think_andhra

Think Andhra

@think_andhra ·
8 Nov

ఢిల్లీలో చంద్రబాబు నివాసం.. జన్‌పథ్‌ 1లోని 100 ఏళ్ల చారిత్రక భవనానికి కొత్త రూపు!

#Chandrababu #1Janpath #CMResidence #LutyensDelhi #thinkandhra

Reply on Twitter 2119384437049667945 Retweet on Twitter 2119384437049667945 26 Like on Twitter 2119384437049667945 221 X 2119384437049667945

Recent Posts

  • Sonal Talpada Vs Veerbhan Singh on 2 Jun 2026 November 16, 2026
  • Dhananjay Rathi Vs Ruchika Rathi on 13 Apr 2026 November 16, 2026
  • Deepika Jimesh Ranawat Vs Jimesh Mahendra Ranawat and Ors on 23 Oct 2026 November 16, 2026
  • Vivek Agrawal Vs Sarita Agrawal and Anr on 31 Aug 2026 November 16, 2026
  • Ritu Gupta Vs Anupam Bipul on 12 Mar 2026 November 16, 2026

Most Read Posts

  • Parvinder Singh Khurana Vs Enforcement of Directorate on 19 May 2026 (1,301 views)
  • Pune Bar Association Vs Union of India on 22 May 2026 (974 views)
  • Sachin Arora Vs Manju Arora on 02 Jul 2026 (625 views)
  • How to Handle Hostile Witnesses in Criminal Trials – Complete Defence Strategy (595 views)
  • Ravi S Vs Sahana Devi A and Ors on 18 Jun 2026 (592 views)
  • Application for Permanent Exemption from Appearance – Format, Procedure & Sample Draft (547 views)
  • How to File a Complaint Against an Advocate in India – A First-Timer’s Complete Guide (546 views)
  • Birendra Kumar Tiwari Vs Neetu Tiwari on 07 Dec 2022 (472 views)
  • Chidurala Shyamsubder Vs State of Telangana on 27 Aug 2018 (466 views)
  • Are BCI and State Bar Councils Statutorily empowered to Levy Fees for Transfer of Enrollment? (465 views)

Tags

Reportable Judgement or Order (456)2-Judge (Division) Bench Decision (441)Legal Procedure Explained - Interpretation of Statutes (392)Landmark Case (391)1-Judge Bench Decision (389)Catena of Landmark Judgments Referred/Cited to (304)Work-In-Progress Article (215)3-Judge (Full) Bench Decision (102)Sandeep Pamarati (92)Article 21 - Protection of life and personal liberty (80)Issued or Recommended Guidelines or Directions or Protocols to be followed (73)Perjury Under Section 340 CrPC (71)Absurd Or After Thought Or Baseless Or False Or General Or Inherently Improbable Or Improved Or UnSpecific Or Omnibus Or Vague Allegations (63)Reprimands or Setbacks to YCP Govt of Andhra Pradesh (49)Summary Post (47)Divorce Granted on Cruelty ground (46)CrPC 482 - Quash (44)Abuse Or Misuse of Process of Court (44)HM Act Sec 13 - Divorce Granted to Husband (43)CrPC 125 or BNSS 144 - Order for Maintenance of Wives Children and Parents (43)

Categories

Supreme Court of India Judgment or Order or Notification (775)Bare Acts or State Amendments or Statutes or GOs or Notifications issued by Central or State Governments (329)High Court of Andhra Pradesh Judgment or Order or Notification (193)High Court of Delhi Judgment or Order or Notification (170)High Court of Bombay Judgment or Order or Notification (113)High Court of Karnataka Judgment or Order or Notification (97)Legal Procedure/Tool (86)High Court of Madras Judgment or Order or Notification (72)High Court of Allahabad Judgment or Order or Notification (64)LLB Study Material (60)General Study Material (56)Assorted Court Judgments or Orders or Notifications (55)High Court of Punjab & Haryana Judgment or Order or Notification (53)High Court of Kerala Judgment or Order or Notification (48)Judicial Activism (for Public Benefit) (47)Prakasam DV Cases (46)District or Sessions or Magistrate Court Judgment or Order or Notification (45)High Court of Madhya Pradesh Judgment or Order or Notification (39)High Court of Telangana Judgment or Order or Notification (29)High Court of Calcutta Judgment or Order or Notification (28)

Recent Comments

  • Aman Kumar on Case Lifecycle Explorer – BNS s.85, DV Act and Maintenance
  • ShadesOfKnife on How to Challenge Ex Parte Orders in Criminal and Matrimonial Proceedings – Legal Remedies
  • pradeep jain on How to Challenge Ex Parte Orders in Criminal and Matrimonial Proceedings – Legal Remedies
  • Lawyer Sonia on Regular Bail Application Format (Section 437/439 CrPC)
  • vinod gupta on Reply to Section 41A CrPC Notice – Format with Legal Explanation

Archives of SoK

  • November 2026 (8)
  • October 2026 (19)
  • September 2026 (13)
  • August 2026 (6)
  • July 2026 (19)
  • June 2026 (19)
  • May 2026 (24)
  • April 2026 (33)
  • March 2026 (42)
  • February 2026 (30)
  • January 2026 (21)
  • December 2025 (2)
  • November 2025 (3)
  • October 2025 (17)
  • September 2025 (12)
  • August 2025 (5)
  • July 2025 (10)
  • June 2025 (15)
  • May 2025 (3)
  • April 2025 (10)
  • March 2025 (7)
  • February 2025 (8)
  • January 2025 (1)
  • December 2024 (3)
  • November 2024 (4)
  • October 2024 (16)
  • September 2024 (15)
  • August 2024 (14)
  • July 2024 (11)
  • June 2024 (18)
  • May 2024 (13)
  • April 2024 (9)
  • March 2024 (23)
  • February 2024 (15)
  • January 2024 (11)
  • December 2023 (11)
  • November 2023 (9)
  • October 2023 (13)
  • September 2023 (12)
  • August 2023 (15)
  • July 2023 (17)
  • June 2023 (11)
  • May 2023 (6)
  • April 2023 (5)
  • March 2023 (10)
  • February 2023 (9)
  • January 2023 (12)
  • December 2022 (12)
  • November 2022 (8)
  • October 2022 (13)
  • September 2022 (17)
  • August 2022 (10)
  • July 2022 (21)
  • June 2022 (27)
  • May 2022 (23)
  • April 2022 (32)
  • March 2022 (17)
  • February 2022 (6)
  • January 2022 (2)
  • December 2021 (7)
  • November 2021 (7)
  • October 2021 (6)
  • September 2021 (10)
  • August 2021 (31)
  • July 2021 (45)
  • June 2021 (17)
  • May 2021 (17)
  • April 2021 (18)
  • March 2021 (58)
  • February 2021 (14)
  • January 2021 (50)
  • December 2020 (35)
  • November 2020 (68)
  • October 2020 (67)
  • September 2020 (28)
  • August 2020 (41)
  • July 2020 (20)
  • June 2020 (36)
  • May 2020 (40)
  • April 2020 (38)
  • March 2020 (26)
  • February 2020 (43)
  • January 2020 (35)
  • December 2019 (34)
  • November 2019 (4)
  • October 2019 (18)
  • September 2019 (57)
  • August 2019 (33)
  • July 2019 (12)
  • June 2019 (18)
  • May 2019 (5)
  • April 2019 (19)
  • March 2019 (58)
  • February 2019 (11)
  • January 2019 (90)
  • December 2018 (97)
  • November 2018 (43)
  • October 2018 (31)
  • September 2018 (73)
  • August 2018 (47)
  • July 2018 (143)
  • June 2018 (92)
  • May 2018 (97)
  • April 2018 (59)
  • March 2018 (8)

Blogroll

  • Daaman Promoting Harmony 0
  • Fight against Legal Terrorism Fight against Legal Terrorism along with MyNation Foundation 0
  • Good Morning Good Morning News 0
  • Insaaf India Insaaf Awareness Movement 0
  • MyNation Hope Foundation Wiki 0
  • MyNation.net Equality, Justice and Harmony 0
  • Sarvepalli Legal 0
  • Save Indian Family Save Indian Family Movement 0
  • Saving Men by Himanshu R Chanda 0
  • SIF Chandigarh SIF Chandigarh 0
  • Unitedmen Foundation a dedicated community forged with the mission to unite men facing legal challenges in marital disputes. 0
  • Vaastav Foundation The Social Reality 0
  • Vinayak my2centsworth – This blog is for honest law abiding men, married or planning to get married 0
  • Voice4india Indian Laws, Non-profits, Environment 0
  • Writing Law Writing Law by Ankur 0

RSS feed: Cloudflare Status Cloudflare Status

  • IAD (Ashburn) on 2026-12-11 December 11, 2026
    Nov 19, 16:50 UTCScheduled - We will be performing scheduled maintenance in IAD (Ashburn) datacenter on 2026-12-11 between 07:00 and 11:00 UTC. Traffic might be re-routed from this location, hence there is a possibility of a slight increase in latency during this maintenance window for end-users in the affected region. For PNI / CNI customers […]
    Cloudflare Status

RSS feed: List of Spam Server IPs from Project Honeypot List of Spam Server IPs from Project Honeypot

  • 35.237.227.191 | S November 19, 2026
    Event: Bad Event | Total: 4 | First: 2026-11-19 | Last: 2026-11-19
Owned and Operated by Advocate Sandeep Pamarati and Advocate Suprajaa Rajan
Proudly powered by WordPress
Theme: Flint by Star Verte LLC

Bad Behavior has blocked 331 access attempts in the last 7 days.

pixel