A two-Judge bench of the Supreme Court held as follows,
From Paras 29 to 31,
29. However, the Respondent-Wife refused to honour the terms of the Settlement Agreement and refused to sign the Second Motion Petition stating that she had withdrawn her consent from the divorce. Though it is well within the law, for any party, to withdraw consent at any stage before grant of divorce by mutual agreement, however, in case a compromise deed or a settlement agreement has been entered in between the parties regarding the full and final settlement of their disputes, then in that case it is not open for the party to step back from the terms and conditions so arrived between them.
30. It is trite law that once the parties have entered into a settlement agreement which was duly authenticated by the mediator, in case of any resilement from such terms as agreed upon in the settlement, the resiling party must be encumbered with heavy costs. Any deviation from the terms of the settlement arrived in mediation and later confirmed by the Court should be dealt with strictly as such deviation harbors an attack to the foundational basis of the entire process of mediation.
31. The exception to the above rule is that a party can resile from the Settlement Agreement arrived in the mediation proceedings is, if it successfully demonstrates that the said Settlement Agreement was procured by force, fraud or undue influence. The party can also resile from the Settlement Agreement on account of non-fulfillment of any of the conditions by the opposite party as set out in the Settlement Agreement.
From Paras 37 and 41 (DV Act proceedings),
37. A careful perusal of the complaint filed by the Respondent-Wife under the DV Act depicts that there are no specific allegations regarding any sort of domestic violence that could emanate from the pleadings. The Respondent-Wife has failed to mention any event describing any sort of violence carried out either by the Appellant-Husband or his mother. A criminal complaint regarding domestic violence, with mere reference to the names of the family members or the husband without any specific allegation that points towards their active involvement in commission of such an act of violence, shall be nipped in the bud.
41. Therefore, we are of the view that the proceedings under the DV Act as initiated by the Respondent-Wife are liable to be quashed, the continuance of which would be an abuse of the process of law.
From Para 53 (Article 142),
53. Thus, in the light of the abovestated facts, we conclude that the present is a fit case for exercise of powers under Article 142(1) to grant a divorce as there had been an irretrievable breakdown of the marriage. Prevailing Position of the Settlement between the Parties
Conclusion: The criminal appeal was allowed, DV Complaint No. 3186/2025 was quashed and the marriage was dissolved under Article 142(1) on the terms of the mediated Settlement Agreement, with all other proceedings between the parties closed (Para 55).
Citations: 2026 INSC 360; Criminal Appeal No. 1924 of 2026 (arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 1878 of 2026).
Other Sources:
https://www.livelaw.in/sc-judgments/2026-livelaw-sc-366-dhananjay-rathi-versus-ruchika-rathi-530195
Index of Divorce Cases here.
Index of Domestic Violence Cases here.