A single judge of Bombay High Court held as follows,
From Paras 23 and 24,
23. For considering whether the prayer under Section 24 of the CPC can be allowed, the parameters permissible under it must be satisfied. Thus, Section 26 of the DV Act, as an enabling and supplementary provision, cannot be interpreted to mean that the Family Court is the competent Magistrate under Section 2 (i) of the DV Act to try and decide the application under Section 25 of the DV Act.
24. The application for modification under Section 25 (2) of the DV Act has been filed seeking modification of the earlier orders passed by the Magistrate in the proceedings initiated by the applicant for grant of maintenance and the rent amount as alternate accommodation under the proceedings initiated under Section 18 of the DV Act. The present application for modification is on the ground of a change in circumstances, as permissible under sub-section (2) of Section 25 of the DV Act. Since the learned Magistrate passed the original order under the DV Act, the competent court to decide the application for modification under sub-section (2) of Section 25 of the DV Act is also the learned Magistrate, as defined under the DV Act. As held by the Apex Court in Rakesh Malhotra, the basic order passed by the concerned court would, by its very nature, exercise the powers of modification.
From Paras 27 and 28,
27. Although the Family Court is empowered to grant reliefs under the DV Act as specified under Section 26, Section 25 is not included among the reliefs provided under the enabling and supplementary Section 26. In view of the specific powers conferred upon the learned Magistrate under the DV Act, Section 26 of the DV Act, which is only an enabling provision, would, therefore, not be the criterion to transfer the modification application by ignoring the jurisdiction conferred upon the Family Court as per Section 7 of the Family Courts Act, 1984, when the original DV proceedings are decided by the Magistrate. Thus, in the absence of any specific jurisdiction conferred upon the Family Court to decide the application under Section 25 of the DV Act, the discretionary powers under Section 24 of the CPC cannot be exercised. Hence, the prayer made in the present application cannot be granted. The application is, therefore, dismissed.
28. It is clarified that the observations and findings recorded in this order are limited to the decision on the application under Section 24 of the CPC. Hence, the modification application pending before the learned Magistrate shall be decided on its own merits in accordance with law, uninfluenced by any observations in this order.
Conclusion: The wife’s application under Section 24 CPC to transfer the husband’s Section 25(2) DV Act application from the Magistrate at Andheri to the Family Court was dismissed. The Court did not decide the maintenance modification itself (Para 28).
Citations: 2026:BHC-AS:43444;
Other Sources:
https://www.livelaw.in/high-court/bombay-high-court/family-court-lacks-jurisdiction-decide-dv-act-maintenance-modification-557170
Index of Domestic Violence Cases here.