A single judge of Chhattisgarh High Court held as follows,
From Paras 15 and 19,
15. One of the most significant subsequent developments is the criminal case instituted by wife/respondent No.1 against the husband/appellant. The appellant has placed on record the judgment dated 17.03.2026 by which he was acquitted in Criminal Case No.372/2021. Mere filing of a criminal complaint or the mere fact of acquittal cannot automatically be treated as matrimonial cruelty. A spouse is entitled to approach the police or the criminal Court where there is a genuine grievance. The question is whether, in the facts and circumstances of the present case, the accusations and the prosecution arising therefrom were of such nature and effect that they caused mental cruelty to the appellant.
19. In view of the aforesaid legal propositions, this Court is of the considered view that on complaint made by wife, the husband was inculpated in criminal case but that criminal case was ultimately culminated in his acquittal. Therefore, in view of the aforesaid law laid down by the Apex Court, this Court is of the view that false accusation made by wife against the husband under Section 498-A/34 of the IPC amounted to mental cruelty caused to the husband and such conduct of the wife certainly caused agony / pain and suffering on various counts to the husband, which made it impossible for him (husband) to lead future marital life with the respondent/wife.
From Paras 20 and 22,
20. Further, the insistence of a spouse for a separate matrimonial home, by itself, cannot invariably be characterised as cruelty. A spouse may legitimately seek separate residence where there exists a reasonable and justifiable basis, particularly where the matrimonial environment is demonstrably oppressive or unsafe. The question, therefore, is not whether a wife can ever ask her husband to reside separately from his parents, but whether, in the facts and circumstances of the particular case, the persistent insistence was justified or whether it constituted an unreasonable attempt to compel the husband to sever or substantially alter his relationship with his parents.
22. Tested on the aforesaid standard, the present case stands on a different footing from a case where the wife merely expresses a preference for an independent household. Here, the appellant’s mother is very old and ailing and this fact has not been disputed by the respondent/wife. The appellant’s explanation that he was unwilling to abandon or distance himself from his ailing mother is, therefore, neither unnatural nor unreasonable. On the contrary, it reflects a legitimate familial obligation which the appellant was entitled to take into consideration while deciding his place of residence. The appellant’s refusal to accede to the demand for separate residence cannot, in these circumstances, be treated as an act of cruelty towards the respondent. A matrimonial relationship does not confer upon either spouse an unfettered right to compel the other to renounce or abandon pre-existing familial responsibilities. Marriage creates a new family, but it does not, by itself, extinguish the moral and legal responsibilities which a person may owe towards aged or infirm parents.
From Paras 24 and 25,
24. Thus, on appreciation of the evidence available on record, it is found proved that the wife was not only suffering from depression even prior to the marriage, but that the husband had also overheard her inappropriate conversation with Narayan Prasad Mishra (R-2) over the mobile phone, which did not sound good, and had brought the matter to the attention of his in-laws. The wife repeatedly pressurized the husband to live in a separate and larger house, whereas the husband did not want to live separately from his old aged ailing mother. In fact, during her stay there, the mother-in-law had to prepare food separately. For all these reasons, the wife would not only frequently quarrel with the husband but would also return to her parental home many times. Despite all this, the husband took her back with him. Nevertheless, there was no change in her behaviour, and since 2019, she has not only been living separately from her husband but has also falsely implicated him in Criminal Case No. 372/2021 on allegations of dowry harassment. In the said case, the husband was acquitted by the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Pendra Road, District Gaurela-Pendra-Marwahi, Chhattisgarh, vide judgment dated 17-03-2026. But without considering the aforesaid evidence, the learned District Judge has dismissed the divorce petition filed by the husband/ appellant, is not found to be sustainable.
25. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the considered view that the appellant/husband has successfully established that the conduct of the respondent No.1/wife, viewed cumulatively, caused him mental cruelty and made continuation of the matrimonial relationship difficult. Hence, this Court is inclined to grant decree of divorce in favour of the husband.
The husband’s appeal under Section 28 of the Hindu Marriage Act was allowed, the District Judge’s decree dated 18.02.2025 was set aside and the marriage was dissolved (Para 26).
Citations: 2026:CGHC:38262; FA(MAT) No. 156 of 2025.
Other Sources:
https://www.caseon.in/case/vivek-agrawal-vs-sarita-agrawal
https://www.shoneekapoor.com/legal-news/wife-pressured-husband-to-leave-his-ailing-mother-then-filed-false-498a-case-chhattisgarh-high-court-grants-him-divorce
Index of Divorce Cases here.